Vol. 23 · 1950 edition
Up From Below the Bottom
A starting point
Palmer’s opening explanation distinguishes the educated and Innate aspects of a person. His deliberate use of plural pronouns provides a starting point for exploring the philosophical framework of this later writing.
Palmer’s opening explanation of his pronouns ties the educated self to the Innate and also acknowledges the people who contribute to his work. Elsewhere, travel anecdotes and pointed stories become occasions to test an idea, including an account of a shipboard lecturer used to question a claim about mind and matter.
The writing rewards attention to how a story is doing philosophical work. Ask what conclusion Palmer wants the reader to draw, and whether the example establishes it or mainly makes it memorable. This approach helps connect the book’s conversational episodes with the more formal distinctions developed elsewhere in the collection.
Original overview · AI-assisted editorial interpretation
A question to take with you
Why does Palmer use we and us when explaining Innate and educated intelligence?
Explore this question with a cited answer, or bring your own interpretation to the book’s Roundtable room.
Explore with Ask B.J.Your question will be filled in for you to review. Ask B.J.’s existing account and daily question limits apply.
Bring it to the Roundtable
Which passage helps explain this book’s central idea? What would you ask another reader? Include a book and page reference when sharing an interpretation.
Visit this book’s discussion room